Review: Justice League Dark

Justice League Dark #1

There’s a lot going on in the wonderfully busy Justice League Dark.  Rather than going for the slow-burn that Johns took in Justice League a few weeks back, Peter Milligan has introduced us to all the books major players, set up a major bad guy, and raised the stakes considerably.  Milligan has an uphill battle to fight with this book, dealing as it does with characters even casual fans will have never heard of, but for the most part he has crafted a confident, unsettling debut that, unlike most books of the relaunch, might actually move a bit too quickly.

Mikel Janin’s art is fantastically expressive, and he does a good job at evoking the weird horror of the threat the new team of magicians and oddballs will be  combating.  It seems a powerful witch, trapped in a small house in the middle of nowhere, has started to go mad – and she’s driving the world mad with her.  Superman, Wonder Woman and Cyborg are quickly defeated, and a new team begins gathering to save the world from a threat few people even begin to understand.  Meanwhile, one lone, confused woman – June Moone – seems to be the epicenter of these bizarre happenings.

There’s very little character work done in Justice League Dark – it’s all plot, all forward momentum.  We get to know a little bit about some of our central heroes.  Shade, who a madman with a dark streak and the ability to manipulate reality, is lonely and desperate not to get involved.  Zatanna, powerful and confident, is a woman used to getting what she wants – and used to standing up to figures like Batman.  Madame Xanadu, worldly, wise and tired beyond measure, may be the only one who truly understands the threat they face.

But are these flashes enough to entice new readers to stick with the book?  It’s conceptually solid, and the first big plotline looks like it’ll be a doozy, but Justice League Dark #1 gives you little reason to care about the characters.  Still, Milligan shows a deft hand at characterizing his cast through small gestures and brief moments, and Janin’s art is perfect for the book.  All this suggests a promising debut, albeit one that may require time to really grow into something truly fantastic.  There’s a lot of ambition here, and Milligan only occasionally overreaches.

– Cal Cleary

All-Star Western #1

Aquaman #1

Batman the Dark Knight #1

Blackhawks #1

The Flash #1

The Fury of Firestorm #1

Green Lanterns New Guardians #1

I, Vampire

The Savage Hawkman #1

Superman #1

Teen Titans #1

Voodoo #1

more on DC’s new 52


4 thoughts on “Review: Justice League Dark

  1. I decided on a whim to pick this up – mostly for opening to a random page I saw Cyborg got some time in it while at the comic shop. The art is amazing, but I don’t think I’ll keep up with this after a few issues. Mostly as this is a type of story style I usually don’t get into (plus Deadman is in it and I generally don’t like him). John Constantine at least has some slight help of recognition from the recent movie, and I love Zatana’s new look. Wasn’t too stoked about Shade and Xanadu though in the slight bit we got to see.

    I do want to state as well that I wasn’t a fan of how Cyborg came off to me. This is our first look at Cyborg as Cyborg in the relaunch and I feel like he got treated like a kid by Superman. That just didn’t sit well with me for in the old universe Cyborg was a character who had been around for years and seemed generally respected by the hero community. In this new universe he’s suppose to have been hanging with the JL for five years and a founder of it. Also his dialogue came off like he was constantly complaining to me.

  2. Agreed. I’m definitely onboard too.

    I haven’t loved a lot of these characters in the past, so I hope they can endear me to them. And, while I expect some wacky in a magically-themed book, I hope it doesn’t get too crazy because I have trouble relating to those stories. Shade worries me as a character for that reason. I didn’t enjoy Flashpoint Secret Seven.

  3. Pingback: Bali Adventure Tours - Bali 4WD Adventure by

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s