Review: Batman #5

Batman #5

I haven’t reviewed Scott Snyder’s Batman in awhile.  It’s not because I haven’t been reading, or because it hasn’t been worth discussing.  By and large, I don’t review it on a monthly basis because openly gushing month after month would grow embarrassing pretty quickly — and this is a book worth gushing about.  Batman #5 continues Snyder’s winning streak, telling a chilling story that pits Batman against a truly worthy foe in a creepy, surreal, issue-long manhunt.

Captured by the Court of Owls, Batman finds himself wandering an elaborate labyrinth, hunted by a foe he couldn’t defeat at full health and slowly starving.  Not sure how he got there in the first place, not even completely sure where he is, Batman prowls the lavish maze looking for something, anything he can use as leverage against the Court of Owls, even anything that will help him get out of there in one piece.

When Greg Capullo first started working on the book, I saw a lot of criticism about his stylistic choices.  And while it’s true that he lacks the technical mastery and design ambition of J.H. Williams III or the brooding Bat-hunk Finch is using, to me, Capullo’s slightly more cartoonish take was a more instantly iconic look.  And I very firmly believe that, with this issue, Capullo and his art team (Jonathan Glapion and FCO) should have silenced all doubters.  In addition to the wonderfully insane labyrinth – which they use to disorient the reader, too, playing games with paneling and even orientation – they deserve credit for crafting Batman’s subtly unhinged look.  Jumping from darkness to light, from color free to bright splashes of red, the book is a visual feast, and every trick employed just pulls you deeper under Snyder’s spell.

The issue ends with a potent symbolic explosion, and with a child missing his father.  And that’s why Snyder’s Batman: The Black Mirror made our best graphic novels of the year list last year, and why there’s a pretty fair chance his current arc will make it this year.  Snyder is willing to terrify us.  He’s willing to put Batman up against amazing enemies.  He’s willing to give us tightly-plotted stories and decades-long conspiracies.  But he never forgets that the heart of Batman is in the characters.  It’s in Damian, longing for his father.  It’s in Gordon, faithful when no one else is.   It’s in Bruce Wayne, lost in the darkness.

If you read one Batman book, this is the one you pick.

Cal C.


5 thoughts on “Review: Batman #5

    • There was no way I could not talk about it. From the page rotations to the sheer friggin’ STYLE of the labyrinth to poor little Damien, this issue was just a blast to read from start to finish. Exactly what I like from my Batman comics.

      I really enjoyed your write-up, by the way. It was more in depth than mine, and the addition of scans really helps sell how Capullo was so fantastic this issue.

  1. I nearly did a review myself, but was short on time at the moment I read it. One thing I kind of disliked about it was the tease of seeing Dick and Damian together (like another comic had couple issues back) but so far not having gotten to see them working together. But yeah, the issue was really nicely handled.

    And yes, gushing does get old fast. Like my lack of Men of War reviews for the past couple issues…

    • Well, supposedly, the Batman books – Batman, Batman & Robin, Batgirl, Catwoman, The Dark Knight and Nightwing (not Detective, and Red Hood/Titans only to limited degrees) – will be part of a cross-over in a few months called “The Night of Owls”. Snyder has been stressing online that you won’t have to read them all to ‘get’ it, and can easily just keep reading whatever titles you want… but given the nature of the crossover, maybe you’ll get your Dick/Damian team-up then?

  2. It has been a fantastic read thus far, and this issue was one of my favorites. Great review; couldn’t have said it better myself. Can’t wait to see how Snyder progress with the Court of Owls storyline.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s