Review: Batman and Robin #1

Last week I felt Daniel had dropped the ball when writing Detective Comics #1 (though some newer readers like Comic Kata thought otherwise).  This week Tomasi is the one taking on the Batman oriented issue in Batman & Robin.


To begin, I want to say I was also a big fan of Dick and Damian’s run together, and my biggest concern about this new Batman & Robin is the mixing of Bruce’s Batman with Damian’s Robin.  I also want to state I enjoyed at least most of Tomasi’s run on the previous Batman and Robin title, so I did go into this one with some faith.  So time to get rolling!

This issue starts off seeing what appears to be the Moscow Batman (who oddly reminds me of Jason Todd’s Batman during Battle for the Cowl) being taken down from someone who claims to be “Nobody”.  If that is the character’s name is a little unclear to me at this moment.  We then jump to Wayne Manor.  This part mostly I think is done for the benefit of new readers who aren’t familiar with the story of what drove Bruce to become Batman, and also to set up a little bit of the relationship Bruce and Damian have.  Pretty much Bruce is preparing to tell Damian fully what happened to his parents.  Damian on the other hand is a bit snippy stating he already knows, that he thinks Bruce doesn’t trust him (which at the time Bruce denies it), and that Damian thinks Bruce constantly making tributes to death as a waste of time.  For now Bruce mostly ignores Damian as they go through the sewers of Gotham to the point Bruce’s parents were killed and he recollects the night it happened, but that he plans to move on finally as well as letting us know that Park Row is about to be restored into a place where people should be able to work and feel safe at again.  During these scenes despite Damian constantly mouthing off, it just didn’t fully come across as being the Damian we got to know when he was teamed up with Dick.

Alfred soon calls them to inform about a matter at Gotham U that needs their attention, and so the new duo races off to stop a group stealing irradiated fuel.  The fight is well handled and despite Batman often chastising Robin, we see that they mostly appear to work well together.  Or so it would seem through the point Batman uses a Batarang to give Damian a hand hold to keep from falling.  As some of the thieves escape though we soon get to see why Damian thought earlier that Bruce didn’t trust him.  Robin takes pursuit and Bruce first tells him “No, don’t follow them without me.”  From there Batman continues over comms to tell Robin to not continue after them, though Robin doesn’t listen and the escapees it seems end up accidentally shooting one of the cans of irradiated fuel killing themselves.

After Batman manages to keep the fuel rods from blowing up, he then meets back up with Robin to again chastise him.  Robin now mouths back more in a manor I’m use to finally in which it really seems full on like it is Damian.  I’d assume at the start he may have just been trying to hold back a little to keep from angering Bruce.  Mostly though the kid points out two things: that he isn’t Tim, Jason, or Dick as he was trained since birth to do work like that, and that even Dick had trusted him (giving us our first hint in the new 52 that Damian and Dick worked together in the past and which could be taken further to guess that Dick probably did act as Batman for a while) and asking why Bruce can’t trust him.  To contradict what he said at the start of the night, Damian is now told that he has “to earn it” and that he’ll inform Damian when the boy has earned it.  The comic then cuts back to the Moscow Batman and Nobody just before Moscow Batman is killed and to set up the fact that Nobody (assuming that is his name) is working on destroying what can only be assumed as Batman Incorporated and that his next target is Bruce Wayne.

This is a very solid issue which I’ll definitely keep up with in later issues, at least if Tomasi can continue writing stories like this.  It does a nice job explaining to new readers what got Bruce into being Batman, his relationship with Damian (as well as good insight into Damian himself), and gave us a nice bit of action while setting itself up to continue the story in later issues.  The duo between Damian and Bruce is made pretty clear from the start though that it is more of a father son thing than partners, and at the end is fully stated by Batman that Damian is not his partner but his son.  This is giving us a new take on the duo of Batman and Robin, though one I have to admit I was expecting since I first heard about this relaunch and that the new Batman & Robin would be Bruce and Damian.  Despite having expected it, I do think Tomasi does a great job handling the relationship.

Great art, great story… My only complaint on this is that I just don’t think the partnership hits quite the same level as Dick and Damian’s previous Batman and Robin.  Mostly I loved seeing Dick grin and let Damian make mistakes and be a Batman who was generally easy going while Damian’s Robin was typically the more darker of the two.  Still as I said earlier, Tomasi does a great job writing this new duo.  I can only wonder how Tomasi will continue to have this relationship evolve, and hope that there will be some team ups between Nightwing and Robin.

Deathstroke #1

Demon Knights #1

Frankenstein, Agent of Shade #1

Green Lantern #1

Legion Lost #1

Mr. Terrific #1

Red Lanterns #1

Resurrection Man #1

Superboy #1

Suicide Squad #1

More on DC’s new 52


About xxadverbxx

I'm a fan of comics. I use to love DC, but events pretty much starting with the New 52 had pushed me off of them for years. Lately though titles like Gotham Academy and We Are Robin have brought me back to them. I'm much more still a Marvel fan though at this moment who I moved to since New 52 slowly kept pushing me away from DC. Often a fan of X-Men titles while I've really been loving Spider-Gwen series. Film wise I'm upset at DC though I really really want them to do good. At least their TV series are mostly enjoyable (though Arrow has dipped in quality), while I'm a huge fan of the Marvel films. Also, I still really hate Dan Didio and still view him as at least most of what has been going wrong with DC comic wise lately.

10 thoughts on “Review: Batman and Robin #1

  1. Great review, I like how you provide a story overview as well as an opinion, because as a new reader it’s good to compare exactly what I interpreted with a more experienced reader’s take.

    Having said that, what do you think the henchman is using after he says, “It’s diversion time!”?

    • Haha! It was kind of an odd line, and I admit I’m a little confused to just what is going on exactly in the panel after that. Still, there have been a lot worse and more awkward lines popping up in these new 52s so I was able to easily ignore that one. Superboy has “Brrr. So scary am you.” Detective Comics has “I own the night!” and Action Comics has “That ain’t Superman”. So yeah, there are those and a lot more awkward lines about these new 52. I don’t know if some of them at least are done on purpose or if a lot of this is being rushed so editors/proof readers just miss things or what.

      • Sorry, I think you misunderstood my question. I didn’t mean to highlight that ine of dialogue as being cheesy what I meant was, what did the henchman USE as the diversion?

        To me it looked as though he let off some sort of explosive, which threw Robin up in the air from where he was, pummeling that other henchman, to the point where Batman threw a Batarang that became a hand hold for Robin.

        It’s that whole action sequence in the reactor, which confused me really as to what exactly is happening.

      • Oh, yeah. I’m assuming it was an explosion but that is part of why the following panel confuses me. It almost looks like he blew up the guy Damian was attacking at the time, and somehow seems to have put the rods in danger of blowing up which meant Batman had to stay behind to deal with it first.

  2. “That ain’t Superman” has a purpose though – it’s preceded by Superman telling the cops that law and order should work both ways for the rich and poor alike.

  3. I think I’ll pick up this title on the strength of this review. It sounds interesting and I had heard good things about Batman Inc. prior to all this New 52 stuff kicking off.

    You know where I’m coming from with this stuff so I am curious to see how confused I get reading multiple Batman titles at two different points in his development. Also I understand that the actual Batman title is due out next week so I should be sufficiently confused by then! lol

    • Justice League is currently in the past, but in general the other things with Batman in them (so far at least) are current time. I do understand that if you are reading multiple titles with the same character playing a major role in each one that it can be confusing keeping things straight but generally each story is happening at different times. That may not be the best way to explain it I know.

      The local comic shop had told me DC was going to try and make things less confusing in regards to that, but I’m not really sure how they can (especially with Batman being in at least 5 comics) and so far haven’t seen any indications that they have.

      • DC have failed at making things less confusing. As jumping on points some of the titles don’t offer the new reader an easy way in. Justice League works only in terms of introducing some of the members that will eventually form the league but not in explaining each separate character (rightly so in my opinion).

        Action Comics has done a good job on the origin story for a new take on Superman (loved it) but then Green Lantern sounds like it relies heavily on knowing the backstory of the characters.

        I think that when DC refer to ‘new readers’ they may mean people familiar with the characters enough to understand their backgrounds from other media (such as movies) without them needing to be spelt out. That’s why I think we’ll see better introductions for less mainstream characters.

  4. I think that is one of the bigger reasons I liked this issue was seeing the dynamic. I may not be a dad but I am a son and have read enough Bruce stuff and around 90% of things with Damian in it that I caught the change in them.

    I’m just not sure if at the end Bruce realized he didn’t trust Damian, or being rather knew to the father thing (as face it, he has barely spent time with Damian until now) that he doesn’t realize its not distrust but more concern as Damian is his son.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s