Review: Incognito #3


The team of Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips rarely disappoints.  Sleeper set the bar pretty high for superpowered noir, and Criminal maintained a consistently high caliber throughout its existing stories, easily becoming the best crime comic on the shelves.  Incognito is their most recent outing, and three issues in, it’s a doozy.

The story is simplicity.  A major supervillain goes into witness protection after a shocking betrayal, but finds that he just can’t quite cope with normal life.  The book maintains a darkly comedic tone throughout this issue as we meet a number of Zack’s old compatriots, criminals who now know where their snitch buddy is hiding, and see Zack’s already precarious cover story tumble into nonexistence.  It seems as though Incognito is moving far faster than it should, but that may be part of the charm – each issue, and this one more so than most, is packed with action, fresh faces, and new problems for out… hero?… and enough genuine emotion to keep us invested in Zack Overkill.

The art, by Phillips, is largely phenomenal, though it functions much better when he’s working in in a slightly dimmer, dirtier setting.  Compare the semi-cartoonish feel of the introduction of renegade criminal Ava Destruction at the book’s beginning as she stands in full daylight in the great outdoors, holding a futuristic laser pistol to the head of a former fed, to the book’s closing scene, featuring another new character met in a darkened apartment.  Nonetheless, it’s been quite a while since I last saw Phillips cut loose with some superpowered action scenes, and his work on this issue was top-notch.

Ultimately, despite the horrible things happening regularly in Incognito, the easy confidence of Phillips and Brubaker make it a pleasure to read, easy to enjoy and strangely easy to become invested in a man with very few redeeming qualities.

Grade: B+

3 thoughts on “Review: Incognito #3

  1. “…easily becoming the best crime comic on the shelves.”

    Not easily, Scalped rivals it, even beats it in some eyes.

    I’m reading Incognito in trade. It seems like the Brubaker/Phillips machine is once again cranking out stellar work. That lettering bothers me though.

    We both wrote new reviews. Hooray us!

  2. I’m still getting caught up on Scalped, but while Scalped has some pretty stellar work being done on it, it’ll be tough to judge before the wrap-up because of the long-form thing it’s got going.

    Still, you’re right, with Scalped around, Criminal does at least have some serious competition. I’m actually a trade behind on both right now, but I’ll probably pick up one of ’em next week.

  3. Well, if that means that you’re about to read Bad Night and Dead Mothers, then you’re in for a real treat because those are my favorite trades from both books.

    Oh wait, you haven’t read them. What I meant to say is that they’re terrible reads. You should still read them, but only to see just how terrible a book can be.

    Actually, the second Scalped trade may be my favorite, but as you said, it’s hard to say. Scalped is an ongoing epic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s