Review/RANT: Incredible Hercules #113

As the title suggests, this will not be your regularly scheduled review. I will rant, perhaps excessively, but within that rant you will find the popcorn kernel of an argument attempting to explode into your face! I will then present to the jury, empirical evidence in the form of scans from numerous Marvel comics from the last year or two to prove my theory. Including this issue of Hercules and this month’s Secret Invasion. My rant will be brutal and sometimes immature and hard to read. But, the argument I present is valid, and if you can look past the ridiculous fanboy ravings, you will see that I have a reasonable complaint and that Marvel editorial needs to sit up and take note.* Thus properly qualified, I begin my review/rant.

Event fatigue has finally set in for the Marvel Universe, and for me. The straw that broke my back? In this issue of Hercules: a Helicarrier falls from the sky. Hmm, sound familiar?

Recent Examples of “Downed Helicarriers” in the Marvel Universe:

1) New Avengers #23: HYDRA unleashes something like an EMP (Electromagnetic Pulse) that destabilizes a Helicarrier and very nearly crashes it into Manhattan.
2) Ultimates 2 #9: The Ultimate versions of the “Masters of Evil” launch an attack on the US that results in the “knocking out of the sky” of dozens of S.H.I.E.L.D. Helicarriers.
3) Mighty Avengers #3: Ultron introduces a virus into the S.H.I.E.L.D. network that crashes a Helicarrier.
4) Secret Invasion #1: The Skrulls introduce an alien virus into the S.H.I.E.L.D. network that crashes a Helicarrier.
5) Incredible Hercules #113: Amadeus Cho introduces a virus into the S.H.I.E.L.D. network that crashes a Helicarrier.
6) Irredeemable Ant Man #2: In a flashback to “Wolverine: Enemy of the State”, the Helicarrier crashes after an attack by super powered HYDRA forces, or what I like to call “Assault on Helicarrier 13”.**
7) Hulk #2: Stark’s red and gold Helicarrier is knocked out of the sky during a fight with the new, red Hulk. Oh the humanity.***

During World War Hulk, the Hulk threatened to crash the Helicarrier, but Dum Dum promised not to mess with him. It’s funny; the one guy you’d think would be all about fucking up S.H.I.E.L.D. allows cooler heads to prevail.

Now, three of the five (now seven) examples presented were perpetrated by one Brian Micheal Bendis. Bendis likes to recycle plot ideas and devices. I’m sure everyone remembers the “storming the Helicarrier” incidents where Dr. Strange used magic twice, within the span of a few weeks, to break into and out of a heavily guarded Helicarrier. There was a tiny bit of backlash here, but nothing to ruin careers. But, that wasn’t the first or last time Bendis would “steal” from himself. Ask yourself, how many times has Bendis had the Iron Man armor malfunction or be ripped from Stark’s body forcefully? With no research, I can say that off the top of my head I can remember five incidents and two more written by Mark Millar.

The Iron Man armor “malfunctions”:

1) New Avengers #18: The Collective Man rips off Stark’s armor when Tony tries to confront him.
2) New Avengers #23: During HYDRA’s assault on the Helicarrier, the EMP they unleash also takes out Stark’s armor.
3) Civil War #5: Captain America uses an “Electron Scrambler” to incapacitate the armor.
4) New Avengers #25: Random dude hacks Iron Man’s armor and incapacitates him.
5) Civil War #7: Again, Captain America takes out Iron Man, this time using Vision to disrupt his armor systems.
6) Mighty Avengers #1: Ultron takes over Stark’s armor and turns him into a girl.
7) Secret Invasion #1: A skrull posing as Jarvis uploads a virus that not only takes down the Iron Man armor, but also every piece of technology it’s linked to including the Helicarrier (see above), the prisons, etc…

Speaking of the prison system… how many breakouts have we seen since the first issue of New Avengers?

Breakouts since New Avengers #1:

1) New Avengers #1: Electro breaks into the Raft and frees a ton of B-list villains.
2) New Avengers #37: The Hood breaks into what appears to be the Helicarrier and frees all his super villain buddies.
3) Secret Invasion #1: The aforementioned Skrull virus takes down The Raft and The Cube, not to mention Bendis having Mar-Vell attack Thunderbolts Mountain. For those paying attention at home, Thunderbolts Mountain has a detention block.
4) Incredible Hercules #113: Amadeus Cho’s virus also breaches Prison Alpha’s security in the Negative Zone. Funny that the Cho virus takes down Prison Alpha but the Skrull virus doesn’t.

What else? Okay, as I mentioned in my Secret Invasion review, I could go back and show you a scene from over 10 years ago that mimics the Skrull Pym/Mr. Fantastic takedown and the blowing up/sucking into the Negative Zone Baxter Building scenes… but I won’t, because after 10 years, it’s okay to steal from yourself in my book. Everything works in cycles, right? But recycling plot devices that are less than a year old, with nothing to connect them, that’s just lazy. Maybe Bendis will prove me wrong? Maybe all these attacks on S.H.I.E.L.D. security are related? Maybe some, I’ll give him that, but not all.

Oh, I thought of some more overused plot devices… blowing up buildings in New York:

1) New Avengers #25: Random dude threatens to set off some bomb that will completely envelop Avengers Tower and suck it into a black hole. He fails, but the idea is still represented.
2) Civil War #7: During the final battle between the registered and unregistered heroes, dozens of buildings are damaged or destroyed.
3) World War Hulk #2: During their fight, Hulk and Iron Man knock down Avengers Tower. And that’s not even considering all the buildings that were destroyed during the entire WWH event.
4) Secret Invasion #1: The Baxter Building getting sucked into the Negative Zone. Also, when that carrier crashes, how many buildings do you think that took out?

Heard enough? It’s easy to see Bendis is the biggest offender. I’m positive I missed some examples, my comic book knowledge is extensive, but my memory is not-so-good. So, I offer a “No-Prize” to the person or persons who point out an incident I failed to mention.

The Reasons I have a problem with all these so called “disasters”:

1) Iron Man armor: After the Extremis Upgrade, Tony Stark’s armor is supposed to make him near-impervious to outside attacks such as viruses. Even without Extremis, Stark is a genius. Why hasn’t he upgraded his anti-virus software? At the very least, his armor should be EMP protected.
2) SHIELD Helicarriers: How cheap must these things be that S.H.I.E.L.D. doesn’t invest in better firewall tech? So tired of these things falling out of the sky like rain.
3) Prison Breaks: This one isn’t so bad, as it happened once at the beginning and once again at the start of the end of the Bendis Skrull epic. We do have some random prison breaks in the middle, like Cho’s virus and Daredevil busting out of Riker’s with Punisher, but I’ll let that slide.
4) The Destruction of New York: Okay, enough is enough. Let the city rest. I didn’t read Damage Control, so I don’t know how they explained the clean up process, but I’ll hazard the guess that no matter how they explained it, it won’t satisfy me.

In summation: Marvel, write something fresh!!! Don’t you guys see that when you reuse these tired ideas they lose their dramatic impact!?! “Oh, hey, there goes another Helicarrier. Whatever.” Is that the reaction you want? Because it’s the one you’re getting from me, a diehard Make-Mine-Marvel loyal reader/asshole!!! IT’S FUCKING RIDICULOUS!!! CUT IT OUT!!!

As for the issue itself? It was fine with a little bit of mediocre. Maybe I’m just in a bad mood… I know for sure it was worse than the last issue. That one didn’t have S.H.E.I.L.D. Helicarriers in it.

*Let’s be real, I don’t actually believe that.

**No-Prize for SeventhSoldier

***No-Prize for Pi_3.14159…




13 thoughts on “Review/RANT: Incredible Hercules #113

  1. One or two to add…

    SHIELD Helicarrier collapsing, I’m pretty certain: The Irredeemable Ant-Man. I don’t remember the issue, but I’ll check it out when I get home today.

    Prison break? Didn’t that happen at the end of Runaways/Young Avengers Civil War crossover super-special, or not?

  2. Well, for #1, in your very own favorite series, Cap, Bucky tried to EMP Iron Man and Iron Man basically said, “Oh come on, I’ve prepared for that at this point in time.”
    Have you read She-Hulk during the World Without a Hulk part? Because they go over Helicarriers and them crashing. Oh, and you missed the Red Hulk crashing the Helicarrier in issue 2 of Hulk.
    Hey, who doesn’t like New York? Everybody wants to attack it! Don’t read Damage Control to be satisfied with how they fix the city, but just by itself because it is an awesome mini-series that is very funny.

  3. Yeah, i totally forgot the Ant Man one from the time Wolverine went all psycho.

    NO, i don’t think it was a prison break from an actual prison. i think i remember that they escaped from Marvel Boy’s clutches, but they weren’t actually in The Cube.

    Yes, Iron Man did learn to finally shield his Armor, good catch… and yet his anti-virus still needs updating!!! HAHA.

    Yes, read the She-Hulk stuff but i don’t remember the parts explaining the Helicarrier crashes.

    Oh yeah, how could i forget the crash in Hulk #2… i remember making fun of it now in my review. heh. I’ll have to edit this post now and give you guys credit.

    yeah, i’ve been thinking about getting the Damage Control TPB or picking the series up on the cheap.

    thanks guys.

  4. Well, in She-Hulk, they basically mentioned how no Helicarrier had crashed before one that she crashed, and now they fall all the time. A S.H.I.E.L.D. agent is really pissed off at her for starting the trend of crashing Helicarriers.

  5. It doesn’t surprise me that that bit of minutia showed up in the She-Hulk title, seeing how Dan Slott loves to break the 4th wall. do you happen to remember which She-Hulk crash he’s referring to? if it’s recent enough, i’d love to add it to the list.

  6. I do not remember. If we are counting Ultimate stuff (as you did with Ultimate Helicarriers), then Ultimates 2 had lots of buildings in New York destroyed. Ultimate X-Men has had stuff destroyed from Apocalypse’s attack. Ultimate FF had a chunk of New York moved away, if not destroyed.

  7. See, I don’t have a problem with any of this. I truly believe (and I may be grasping at straws here) that Marvel has been systematically making SHIELD a complete joke since Secret War. They can’t do a damn thing right without Nick Fury. This allows for more ammo for Fury to use when he returns during SI to allow for his rightful return to directing SHIELD.

    As for Stark’s armor, you need to consider that Jarvis uploaded a virus directly into Stark’s mainframe. This wasn’t an attack from without. The same can be said for Ultron’s virus attack that hit the Helicarrier in Mighty Avengers 3. It could easily be a situation that Stark focused so much on trying to repel outside attacks on his systems (after the events of Civil War) that he neglected his internal firewalls.

    And keep in mind that there was a breakout on the Raft prior to New Avengers 1 in the last arc of Alias. That place just sucks at containing people. Kinda surprising that they didn’t put Doom in the Negative Zone prison. Further proof that the current SHIELD is full of buffoons.

    Personally, I’m reserving judgment on Bendis’ repetition techniques until the end of Secret Invasion, because we can’t be sure exactly what’s intentional considering that Secret Invasion’s been in the works since Disassembled.

  8. Pingback: Crime Lords Month: The Task at hand « Lost Hemisphere

  9. The Nick Fury thing is valid reasoning, i’ll concede that.

    The armor thing: all valid excuses… again, i’ll give you that.

    The breakouts… you got that one as well.

    “Personally, I’m reserving judgment on Bendis’ repetition techniques until the end of Secret Invasion, because we can’t be sure exactly what’s intentional considering that Secret Invasion’s been in the works since Disassembled.”

    okay, i agree, he may have had this all planned, but i’m leaning toward not.

    here’s the real issue, i don’t care how they explain this shit. that’s not really the point. it’s the repetition, as you put it, that bugs the hell out of me. no matter how you slice it, it’s bad writing. downing a Helicarrier, fucking with Stark’s armor, prison breaks, etc… these are ALL overused plot devices. every time i see this shit i scream at my comic “WTF WE JUST SAW THIS!!!” i shouldn’t be yelling at my comics like that. there’s really no excuse for giving us the same, specific shit over and over again. and i’m not talking about the larger issue, that comics never really change… i understand it’s all cycles. like, in a few years, we’ll get the old Peter/MJ relationship back. we all know this. i’m not talking about that. i’m speaking of specific incidents that appear over and over with no discernable pattern. for example, how lame would it be if in less than 3 months, Red Hulk destroys Manhattan? and then a few months after that, Skaar shows up and wrecks it again. and then Green Hulk gets out of prison a couple weeks after that and on and on and on…

    as far as supplying us with logical explanations after the fact, any editor or writer worth his salt can come up with something interesting to distract us from the mistakes. obviously, Slott’s explanations for the messed up continuity of the past few years (the Earth A and Earth B explanation) was formulated post continuity problems. i just don’t buy that any of this was well thought out. especially since only 3 of the 7 listed carrier incidents were written by Bendis. that means 3-4 other writers, operating semi-independently, also thought it would be cool to crash a Helicarrier and no one in Marvel editorial thought to mention, “Hey, we just did this over in Avengers or Ultimates… maybe we should put a moratorium on Helicarrier crashes?”

    ugh. i know if i brought this up at a panel (which i would never do), Joe Q would make a snide remark and go on to the next question. anyways, i’m seriously ranting now, so i will stop before it gets too ugly. heh.

  10. But, rants are supposed to be ugly. Ugly rants are good rants. A rant isn’t about saying that ‘maybe this is so’, it’s about saying ‘this is goddamn how it is and it’s beginning to seriously piss me off, so maybe one of you professionals, you know, the twits who get paid to do the job that half of us would do for free, could step up to the plate, grow a pair, and quit this bullshit repetition, because, hey, guess what, you aren’t being clever, you aren’t being cute, that idea isn’t unique this time, wasn’t unique last time, and probably still won’t be unique when you do it again in six god damn weeks.’

    See, you rant out of a genuine passion, which means you have cart blanche to be as insanely out there as possible. I just ranted because I’m a douche bag (see also my current condescending tone), and because I’m tired and it made me giggle. Asides, rant enough, and maybe someday soon you’ll get paid for ranting. After all, look at Zero Punctuation.

  11. i had meant to rant more, but once i started writing this, i found that the fire inside had diminished significantly. the older i get, the harder it is to get worked up about stupid shit. not sure if that’s always a good thing, you know?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s