Mini-Reviews: Catching Up With Comics

November 7, 2008

This is becoming all too common these days.  And unfortunately, it shows no signs of letting up.  Been busy.  So has everyone else, I know.  So, rather than post 1 or 2 full reviews, I’m going to play a little catch-up with some mini-reviews.  I’m going to try to focus on books others haven’t covered.  Or at least books that haven’t been reviewed three and four times.

Daredevil #112 – Last issue, I gave this book a try after a long absence.  I enjoyed the set-up of the Lady Bullseye character.  This issue, we get some interesting glimpses into her plan which seems to involve testing possible recruits to her cause.  But the overall focus of the story seems to be showing what a monumental jerk Matt Murdock is.  I mean, this guy cheated on his wife.  Then he got angry with his mistress when she revealed their indiscretion to the police to clear him of murder charges.  Is he in some kind of a dick-off with Tony Stark?  It was still a good read, but I’m not inclined to keep reading about such an unsypathetic character.

DCU: Decisions #4 – Just the premise of this story should have been enough to tell me it was going to be bad.  Then there’s the fact that it’s co-written by Judd Winick.  I’ve defended Winick in the past, but I’m done with that now.  More and more, he seems determined to live up to his reputation as a hack.  This issue is made up of essentially two parts.  The first part is a non-ending which leads into the next story arc of the horrible Titans book Winick writes.  A four-issue mini should offer some kind of closure, but this one is all set-up for another book.  A really bad book.  The last several pages is nothing more than a public service announcement about the importance of voting.  I had low expectations of this book, but Winick and company managed not to meet them.

Justice League of America #26 – I want to love this book because I love th Justice League.  But McDuffie’s cast is too big.  And his stories, while they may have seemed fresh in the animated series, rehash the most over-used comic book cliches.  Occassionnaly, you’ll get some good character moments.  But all too often, everything is on the surface.  This issue is particularily bad.  After months of build-up, Vixen’s story ends with a return to her status quo.  But not before a trip to a parellel universe!  The pat ending comes out of nowhere like the story just ran out of gas.

Making matters worse is Ed Benes’ ridiculous amount of T&A.  Usually, I don’t mind Benes as a penciller.  But when the story is as thin as this, you can’t help noticing that Vixen’s butt takes up half the panel and her porn star chest takes up the other half.  This is to be expected from Benes.  He has made a name for himself selling cheesecake.  But it feels so out of place in DC’s flagship title.

Justice Society of America #20 – Now this is how you handle a big cast and parellel universes!  There were so many character running around, it was sometimes hard to keep track of who was who.  And there were a whole lot of Earth-2 character I just don’t care about very much.  But Johns, Ross and Eaglesham do a masterful job of shining a spotlight on the emotional impact of the story.  Primarily, we’re dealing with Power Girl here.  We finally get some answers as to how there are two Power Girl’s running around and we feel the loss both characters are feeling.  In the background, we also get important character moments for Alan Scott and Mr. Terrific.  Even with the confusion of having multiple Justice Society’s battling it out, this is just a good, fun comic book.  It puts Justice League to shame!

Reign In Hell #4 – There is a big story being told in this mini-series.  And there are a lot of players.  Most of them don’t even qualify as C-listers.  So, it can be a bit hard to keep track of who is doing what.  I like the stylized art by Tom Derenick and Bill Sienkiewicz, but sometimes it adds to the confusion.  With so much going on, I almost wonder if this mini-series wouldn’t have been better served by a different structure.  Maybe one more like the similar Annihilation story also written by Keith Giffen.  I think I would enjoy each of these stories more if they had been compartimentalized in overlapping mini-series instead of one big story that can’t focus on any one thing for too long.

Secret Six #3 – This book continues to be the most fun read of the month.  It’s twisted, sure.  But it’s hysterical.  And the artwork is amazing.  If you haven’t checked it out yet, it’s time to start.

Superman #681 – First of all, let me say that I am loving the New Krypton story line so far.  The premise is big and ripe with possibilities.  And the New Krypton Special was just that, special.  The scenes drawn by Gary Frank depicting Superman’s reaction to Pa Kent’s death were brilliant!  As the second chapter in the story, this issue does a good job of moving the plot along as well as undercoring what a big deal it is that one hundred thousand Kryptonians have arrived on Earth.  My one complaint is that the cliff-hanger ending literally just drops from the sky.  (My minor quibble is the entire page that was devoted to Krypto asking to be let into the Kent farm – what is it with Robinson and Krypto?!?)

Teen Titans #64 – I really should drop this book.  I’m still reading it out of habit, which is a bad thing.  I understand what Sean McKeever’s been trying to do with this book.  First, he broke down the cast to the point where the team currently has only four members.  Now, he’s slowly rebuilding it by adding members one at a time.  The problem is, neither the departures nor the additions feel organic.  Most of the characters who left the book did so because the plot demanded it.  And in this issue, the team takes in Bombshell for pretty much no reason whatsoever.  Even Bombshell seems amazed by their stupidity.  I should really drop this book…

Terror Titans #2 – Man, this is just pointless!  McKeever introduces characters in a single panel only to kill or maim them in the same panel.  Who the hell cares?  And the over-the-top gore is not cool.  It’s certainly out of place in a mainstream super-hero book.  Especially part of the Titans franchise.  But that franchise is in sorry shape these days.  Sadly, this is just one indicator of how bad things have gotten.


Mini-Reviews: Lebeau Catches Up

September 27, 2008

Hello all,

I just recently got back from an Orlando vacation and I have a stack of comics to read and review/rant about.  On a side note, I finally got to visit Universal’s Islands of Adventure theme park.  If you’re a Marvel fan and you’ve never been down to IoA, you owe it to yourself to plan a trip.  The Marvel Superheroes island is a lot of fun and the Spider-Man ride is one of the coolest attractions anywhere.  Anyway, on to the comics:

Action Comics #869 – The cover to this issue is misleading.  These events do not take place in the comic, nor does anything remotely resembling these events take place.  Instead, we get a whole lot of awesomeness.  Seriously, the Brainiac arc is one for the ages.  Do not miss it!

Batman and the Outsiders #11 - No one knows where Batman is.  I just saved you $2.99.  Not much else happens in this fill-in issue.  The team wonders if they should carry one without Batman which is ridiculous given that this is only issue 11 in a series that follows a very long run of the Outsiders without Batman.  If the team made it for years without him, why on earth would they consider disbanding when Batman goes missing?  This is just padding while Batman RIP plays out.

Birds of Prey #122 - I keep reading this book hoping for a return to glory.  If the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result, I must be crazy.  This book is going to remain a mediocre, run-of-the-mill super hero cliche-fest as long as Bedard is writing it.  And the art is equally dull (I did like the cover though).

Captain America #42 -  Hey look!  A Marvel book!  The epic Death of Captain America story wraps up here.  The payoffs we’ve been waiting for come fast and furious.  And of course there are multiple epilogues setting the stage for the next chapter in Brubaker’s run.  An issue like this could have easily disappointed.  But Bru and Steve Epting deliver a satisfying conclusion.

Daredevil #111 – Another Marvel book?  What the heck?  I haven’t checked in on Daredevil in a while.  This issue seemed as good a time as any as it kicks off the Lady Bullseye story.  So, I came back and I’m glad I did.  In the past, I’ve enjoyed Brubaker’s run on Daredevil but sometimes got frustrated with the pace.  Not so on this issue.  I’ll definitely stay on board to see where this story goes.

Deadpool #2 – For a DC guy, I’m turning into a regular Marvel zombie here…  I hadn’t planned on picking up this issue.  I thought the first issue was a mixed bag.  And I’m pretty sick of Skrulls these days.  But on a lark, I gave issue 2 a try and I’m glad I did.  It was a very entertaining read.  I laughed out loud a few times.  (“The more pouches the better, right Rob?”

DCU: Decisions #1 – I was definitely skeptical about the concept of this mini-series.  I’m still skeptical.  But, the first issue wasn’t the train wreck I was expecting.  Still, is anyone really interested in the political leanings of the JLA?  If you are, you’ll probably enjoy a lot of this.  If not, the entire mini-series is skippable.  For now, I’ll call it surprisingly not horrible.

Flash #244 – Alan Burnett starts what could be the last Wally West story in his own title.  The name of the story arc is certainly ominous.  “This Was Your Life Wally West” has a certain ring of finality to it.  I actually enjoyed the family dynamics in this book for the first time since they were introduced by Mark Waid.  There’s an interesting story involving the fluctuation of Wally’s powers.  Unfortunately, it’s all brought down a little by the villain, a generic bee-guy.  Still, this book hasn’t been readable in a long while.  So, I’ll take what I can get!

Reign in Hell #3 – The cover says it all.  It’s the fight you’ve been waiting for, Etrigan vs. Blue Devil.  What?  You haven’t been waiting for Etrigan to throw down with Blue Devil?  Okay, we’re not dealing with DC’s A-list here.  But I have been enjoying Giffen’s interesting twist on Hell.  He steers clear of the usual Dante’s Inferno imagery and presents a more traditional war story told in an unusual setting.

Robin #178 – Now this is how you do a Batman RIP tie-in!  The issue offers an interesting look at what Robin’s world would be like if Batman really did go missing (unlike the predictable and repetitive Batman and the Outsiders).  The plot threads Nicieza has been building finally start to come together.  Good reading!

Superman #680 – Wow.  James Robinson really loves Krypto!  Still, I have to admit it was pretty cool.  My dog would have been asking Atlas to rub her belly.

Teen Titans #63 – I was one of the many people who thought last issue’s violent and senseless death was a travesty of bad story telling.  (For the curious, Marvin died but Wendy survived and is currently in a soap opera-style coma.)  This issue had no where to go but up.  Still, more than half of the issue was dedicated to rehabilitating Bombshell.  Talk about a wasted effort!  This issue is better than last issue.  But it’s still bad.

Titans #5 – The first four issues of Titans were a train wreck.  And sometimes, you just can’t look away from a train wreck.  Well, I’m going to go out on a limb and say that this issue was actually a vast improvement over the previous four.  (I credit fill-in artist Julian Lopez with the majority of the improvement.  His artwork is still full of needless T&A.  It’s still overly cartoony and not especially good.  But it does not hurt the eyes the way the previous artist did).  Yes, Judd Winick still tries to hard to sound cool.  But there are actually a few good character moments here.  And the plot actually goes somewhere.  So, I damning with faint praise.  Titans got better.  But it still has a long way to go.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,956 other followers